What’s For Dinner: November 2026 Thanksgiving Edition with Allie Hagerty of Seasoned & Salted

November 19, 2026 Story by Marisa Olsen (Images by Natalie Kollee)

Happy November! Hopefully your candy coffers are stuffed,  the faux spiderwebs are packed away, and you’re turning your attention to your Thanksgiving menu.

For this month’s What’s For Dinner, we’re honored to feature Allie Hagerty of Seasoned & Salted, a Hingham-based recipe developer, food blogger, home cook, and future cookbook author.

If you’re not already following Hagerty on Instagram, you should be. Her account centers on her home kitchen, where all the action happens. On camera, Hagerty walks viewers through each recipe in thoughtful detail, sharing her zest for good home cooking with a playful touch.

Hagerty kindly shared several of her recipes, along with a few pro tips for our readers. There’s a simple first course, a classic side with a twist, and a leftover recipe we’ll be making all winter. We hope these recipes brighten up your Thanksgiving table.

Soup’s On

Soup isn’t usually on our radar for Thanksgiving, but a batch of Hagerty’s Creamy Butternut Squash & Sage Soup makes a simple, delicious course. Serve it as a starter or set out a slow cooker so guests can help themselves. Either way, we plan on making this soup all cozy season long.

Allie’s note: This soup is such a great recipe to make the day before Thanksgiving. The flavors deepen overnight in the fridge! Serve it from a slow cooker with fresh toppings like Parmigiano Reggiano, pepitas, or crème fraîche on the side so guests can build their own bowls.

Mashed Potatoes, But Make It Tangy

Mashed potatoes are a must on most Thanksgiving tables, and we’re digging Hagerty’s take with her Creamy Crème Fraîche Mashed Potatoes.

If you haven’t used crème fraîche before, it’s a tangy, French-style cultured cream that you can find at most larger and specialty grocery stores. It also makes an excellent swap for sour cream or thick, plain Greek yogurt.

Allie’s note: These mashed potatoes are so delicious and tangy! Pro tip: You can stir crème fraîche into store-bought mashed potatoes, too. Crazy, I know. Leftovers make an excellent topping for turkey pot pie, or you can fry them up in a skillet for potato pancakes.

Something Other Than a Leftover Turkey Sandwich

As for the leftovers — which we’d argue are the best part — try Hagerty’s Turkey Puff Pastry Pot Pie.

Chicken is the usual star of a pot pie, but turkey adds deeper flavor under that flaky crust. It’s a great way to use up leftover turkey once you’re tired of the traditional post-Thanksgiving sandwich.

Allie’s note: This pot pie is one of my favorites, and I look forward to making it every year after Thanksgiving. Store-bought puff pastry makes it a no-brainer!

Share your Thanksgiving meals and leftovers with us! Tag the Hingham Anchor and Cohasset Anchor, as well as Seasoned & Salted. We can’t wait to see what you make.

Leave a Comment